Get Five free: the five Saudi business stories that matter, in your inbox by 7am. Subscribe →

A new-car showroom

A new-car showroom. Photo: Continentaleurope via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

One customs form, in a post that drew about 740,000 views, has revived an old question: why do new cars in the kingdom cost so much more than they're worth at the border?

The answer turns out to be less dramatic than the post suggests. But the gap that remains is the bigger story.

The post

Economist Fahad Al-Bogami shared the paperwork for a car on sale at a dealer for 579,000 Riyal ($154,400). The customs declaration shows duty of 14,255 Riyal.

At a 5% duty rate, that puts the car's declared value at about $76,000. "How does the selling price get to almost double?" he asked. The post drew about 740,000 views.

What people are saying

Most replies blame the exclusive dealer system, where each brand is sold through a single agent. "Monopoly is the root of the problem," one user wrote, in a reply viewed 77,000 times.

Another did the sum: a gap of about 294,000 Riyal that, he said, belongs to the consumer.

Some said they now buy spare parts online to dodge dealer prices. One user said importing a car yourself doesn't help either, because customs values it at the dealer's price rather than the invoice you paid.

The maths, done properly

The post compares two different things.

Customs duty on cars is 5% of the vehicle's value, and 15% VAT is then charged on the value plus the duty. Dealers can claim that import VAT back, and the 579,000 Riyal sticker price already includes VAT for the buyer.

So compare like with like, before VAT. The declared customs value plus duty comes to about $79,800. The dealer's pre-VAT sticker price is about $134,300.

That's not double. The pre-VAT sticker price is about 68% above the declared customs value plus duty.

Where the other $54,000 goes

Some of it is real cost. Dealers pay for showrooms, multi-year warranties, free servicing, spare-parts stock and cars that sit unsold. A customs value can also leave out costs the distributor carries, such as marketing and local fit-outs.

The customs figure isn't the dealer's full landed cost, so the gap isn't all profit. But $54,000 on a single car is still a lot to explain.

Why it's a live issue

Regulators are already looking. The competition authority has examined economic concentration in car sales, after-sales service and spare parts, and has discussed registering more agents per brand with the Ministry of Commerce.

In August, the ministry suspended a car dealer and fined it 8.12 million Riyal for consumer rights violations.

A new commercial agencies law is also under discussion, and lawyers expect it to bring closer competition scrutiny of exclusive agencies.

The money question

If more agents are allowed per brand, this gap is where competition would bite first. Until then, Saudi buyers will keep doing the maths on X, and dealers will be under pressure to show theirs.

Follow CapitalSA on LinkedIn for the Saudi business stories that matter →

Keep reading